Originally published in Pediatric Dentistry Today (American Academy of Pediatric Dentistry), Q1 2025, “Litch and Associates Law Log.” Co-authored by Cheryl A. Cameron, PhD, JD, C. Scott Litch, MA, JD, and Cheryl H. DeVore, MS, JD (Senior Partner, Thomas Law Group). Read the full article →
Even careful dentists end up under a dental board’s microscope at some point, usually because a patient or parent filed a complaint. How you respond in the first few weeks can shape the outcome. In our Pediatric Dentistry Today column, we walked through how state dental boards handle complaints and what dentists can do to prepare.
Key takeaways
- Your license is a privilege, but it comes with due process. A board cannot take it away without notice and a chance to be heard.
- Call a lawyer when the complaint arrives. The response is time-sensitive, and counsel can help keep the review from growing beyond the original complaint.
- Notify your malpractice carrier. Many policies cover board complaints, but only if you report on time.
- Respond to the board yourself. Don’t hand board letters to staff, and follow the board’s instructions for producing records exactly.
- Read any consent agreement with counsel before signing. Its terms are enforceable and may be public.
Who regulates dentists
Every state has a dental board, commission, or committee with authority to license dentists, write regulations, and discipline licensees. Most members are practicing dentists, and many boards also include hygienists and public members. Ohio’s board includes two dentists recognized as specialists in different specialties.
A board’s first job is protecting the public. That means it monitors compliance with state dental law and can impose sanctions for violations. Specialty licensing rules also vary widely from state to state, so specialists should know exactly what their own state requires.
The four stages of a board complaint
1. The complaint
Complaints usually come from patients or parents, but they can also come from staff, other providers, government agencies, or the board itself. Before anything else happens, the board checks two things: whether the complaint was filed properly, and whether it falls within the board’s authority. Complaints that fail this review are closed and are not made public.
If the complaint moves forward, you will receive notice along with a request for a written response and, often, patient records. The board usually will not tell you who filed it.
2. Inquiry and investigation
An investigation can include record requests, an office visit, an interview, or all three. If the board asks for patient records without a subpoena, ask for one, and make sure HIPAA requirements are met before you produce anything. Missing deadlines or being uncooperative can expand the investigation. If the board wants to meet, try to meet somewhere other than your office.
Many investigations end with no violation found. Those matters are closed and stay private. Minor issues may end with an informal warning or letter of concern, which in some states can become public.
3. Charges and settlement
Common charges include lack of informed consent, incomplete records, failure to meet the standard of care, poor staff supervision, practicing with an expired license, prescribing problems, infection control lapses, billing issues, and missing continuing education. Failing to cooperate with the investigation can be its own charge.
Many cases resolve through a settlement or consent agreement. The charges are dropped as long as you meet the conditions, which can include practice restrictions, extra continuing education, or regular reporting to the board. Whether to accept one depends on the strength of the charges, the cost of a hearing, and your tolerance for risk, much like deciding whether to settle a lawsuit.
4. Hearing and decision
Cases that don’t settle go to a formal administrative hearing, where you can present evidence and cross-examine witnesses. Sanctions range from a reprimand or fine to probation, practice limits, suspension, or revocation. Results are public and are likely to be reported to the National Practitioner Data Bank.
How to lower your risk
- Know your state’s dental laws and make sure your associates and staff follow them, including any specialty licensing and advertising rules.
- Know your reporting duties, such as communicable disease, suspected child abuse or neglect, and serious adverse events.
- Keep your address current with the board, complete continuing education on schedule, and renew your license on time.
- Treat every letter from the board as urgent, and handle it yourself rather than delegating it.
- Bring in legal counsel early and notify your malpractice carrier.
Frequently asked questions
Should I hire a lawyer for a dental board complaint?
Yes. A lawyer can help limit the scope of the review, keep you from volunteering information that widens it, and prepare you for possible charges.
Will a dental board complaint become public?
Not always. Complaints that are dismissed or closed with no violation found stay private. Consent agreements, hearing results, and in some states informal warnings can become public.
Does malpractice insurance cover board complaints?
Many policies do, but coverage often depends on reporting the complaint promptly. Check your policy and call your carrier as soon as you receive notice.
Do I have to give the board my patient records?
Usually, yes. Ask for a subpoena if the board hasn’t issued one, follow its production instructions exactly, and make sure the release complies with HIPAA.
Thomas Law Group helps Ohio dentists respond to dental board complaints and investigations. To talk with an attorney, call 614-761-7701 or contact us.
This article is for general information only and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship.
Related A Dental Board Investigator Is at My Office! What Do I Do?|Mandatory Reporting Requirements for Dentists|Informed Consent for Pediatric Dental Patients
