By: Cheryl H. DeVore On: August 15, 2025 In: Health Care Professionals Comments: 0

Originally published in Pediatric Dentistry Today (American Academy of Pediatric Dentistry), Q3 2025, “Litch and Associates Law Log.” Co-authored by Cheryl A. Cameron, PhD, JD, Cheryl H. DeVore, MS, JD (Senior Partner, Thomas Law Group), and C. Scott Litch, MA, JD. Read the full article →

Informed consent is a legal requirement, and it’s also one of the best tools a dentist has for building trust. With pediatric patients it gets more complicated, because the patient usually can’t legally consent and the adults involved may not all have the right to. Our Pediatric Dentistry Today column covered who can give consent for a child, what to tell them, and when.

Key takeaways

  • Consent usually has to come from a parent or legal guardian. Ask on your intake form who has legal authority to consent, and keep copies of custody or guardianship orders.
  • Some minors can consent for themselves. Emancipated minors and certain treatment categories are exceptions. Document the minor’s legal status in the chart.
  • Consent is a conversation, not a signature. The treating provider should explain the diagnosis, the procedure, the risks, the alternatives, and the option of no treatment.
  • Never guarantee results. Tell families that outcomes can’t be fully predicted.
  • Write it down. Even where a signed form isn’t required, it is strong evidence that consent was obtained.

Who can consent for a child

In most states a person must be 18 to consent to their own health care. For a minor patient, the dentist makes the disclosure to a parent or legal guardian. Divorce, separation, or a custody order can limit which parent has that authority, and dentists generally have to rely on families to tell them. An intake form that asks who holds legal authority to consent is a simple safeguard. If one parent has sole authority or a third party is the guardian, ask for a copy of the court order.

Some states also allow other adults, such as a grandparent or caregiver, to consent if they hold a power of attorney or written authorization from a parent. Get a copy and check that it hasn’t expired.

When a minor can consent

Courts can declare a minor emancipated, and some states treat marriage, active military duty, or parenthood the same way. Many states also let minors consent on their own to certain kinds of care, such as treatment for substance use or mental health. Information shared in those situations is protected health information under HIPAA, which can create a real conflict if the dentist believes a guardian needs to know. If a teenager says they can consent for themselves, ask for documentation and keep it in the record.

Even when a parent gives consent, involving the child in the conversation, to the extent their age allows, usually goes better. Treatment that depends on a child’s cooperation is hard to carry out if the child never agreed to it.

What to disclose

The disclosure should cover who will do the procedure and explain, in plain language:

  • The diagnosis
  • The nature and purpose of the procedure
  • Its likely benefits
  • Known risks, including rare but serious ones a reasonable person would want to know about
  • Alternatives, with their benefits and risks
  • What happens with no treatment

Avoid jargon, keep written materials at about a sixth to eighth grade reading level, and arrange interpreters when needed. For care under general anesthesia, make sure the consent is broad enough to cover changes once treatment begins.

States judge disclosures by one of two standards: what a reasonable dentist would disclose, or what a reasonable patient would consider important. Know which one your state uses.

When to get consent

Get consent before treatment and reasonably close to the treatment date. When a patient is referred, the treating dentist is generally responsible for getting consent, so coordinate with the referring provider if their treatment comes first. In a true emergency where a parent can’t be reached in time, you don’t have to delay care, but document the circumstances and tell the family afterward.

What happens when consent falls short

Missing or invalid consent can lead to negligence or breach-of-contract claims. Treating beyond what was consented to can even support a battery claim. It is also grounds for dental board discipline, and a board doesn’t have to show that a patient was actually harmed.

Best practices for your office

  • Adopt a written policy or checklist on who can consent for minors under your state’s law.
  • Have the treating provider make the disclosure, or at least be available for questions.
  • If families don’t ask questions, prompt them, or ask them to explain the plan back to you.
  • Record every consent discussion in the chart, even when a signed form isn’t required.
  • Treat consent as ongoing, not a one-time form, and learn the specific rules for sedation, protective stabilization, teledentistry, and mobile care in your state.

Frequently asked questions

Can either parent consent to dental treatment for a child?

Usually, yes. But a custody order or other legal arrangement can give one parent sole authority. Ask on your intake form and keep a copy of any court order.

Can a grandparent consent to a child’s dental care?

Only if your state allows it and they have proper authority, such as a power of attorney or signed authorization from a parent. Keep a copy and check the date.

Is a signed consent form enough?

No. The form documents the conversation, but the conversation is what makes consent valid. The family needs to understand the diagnosis, risks, and alternatives.

Can a dentist treat a child without parental consent in an emergency?

Yes, if getting consent in time would harm the patient’s health. Document the emergency and inform the parent or guardian as soon as you can.

Thomas Law Group helps Ohio dental practices put consent policies, intake forms, and office procedures in place that hold up. To talk with an attorney, call 614-761-7701 or contact us.

This article is for general information only and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Related Who Are the Legal Custodians of Minor Children?|Terminating the Dentist-Patient Relationship|Dental Board Complaints: What to Expect